Lucy Hale’s New Horror Movie Looks Scarier Than Every Episode of ‘Pretty Little Liars’

Pretty Little Liars wasn’t a scary TV show, but it did have its creepy moments. Remember the time Aria (Lucy Hale) was covered in rats? Or the time Emily was almost sawed in half? Plus, there’s the fact that Spencer’s evil British twin was pulling the strings for the entire series—like, who the hell saw that coming? For all its campy one-liners and humorous moments, PLL did manage to make us jump every now and then.

But the show pales in comparison to Hale’s new horror movie, Truth or Dare, which hits theaters in April. It centers on a group of very hot young people—including Hale and Teen Wolf star Tyler Posey—who are tricked into playing a game of “Truth or Dare” that actually comes to life. The game literally starts following them after they play one round, and the stakes increase astronomically: If they don’t tell the truth or complete the dare each time, they die. It sounds strange, I know, but it’s executed with enough of a diabolical wink that it works. Well, that’s what this just-released trailer suggests, at least. Watch it for yourself, below:

The game is real. @lucyhale and @tylergposey invite you to play Truth or Dare. Wanna play? Watch the trailer. #TruthOrDareMovie pic.twitter.com/W8bwqfd5NX

— #TruthorDareMovie (@truthdaremovie) January 3, 2018

Yeesh, imagine if the Pretty Little Liars gals had to play this game. They’d all die! All they did for seven straight seasons was lie, lie, lie. And there’s no way Hanna (Ashley Benson) would do a crazy dare. She’d scoff and walk away like the queen she is. (Can you tell that I miss Pretty Little Liars?)

Truth or Dare is slated for an April 27, 2018 release. I’m never playing this game again.

Lucy Hale Called Herself “Fat” on Instagram, and People Are Not Pleased

Lucy Hale Responds to Backlash Over Calling Herself “Fat” on Instagram