Engagement Ring Face-Off: Jennifer Lopez Vs. Jennifer Garner! Which Jen Scored the Best Ring From Ben Affleck?

Before Ben Affleck and Jennifer Garner were the married parents of three, there was another Jenny on Ben Affleck’s block. In 2002, Ben proposed to Jennifer Lopez with a 6.1-carat pink Harry Winston diamond worth a reported $1.2 million. (Pink diamonds don’t come cheap; click here for a better pic.) Bennifer1.0 called off their engagement in 2004. Later that year, Ben made it official with Jennifer Garner when he went back to Harry Winston to buy a 4.5-carat cushion-cut diamond with baguette sidestones. (Click here for a better pic.)

Almost a decade later, Bennifer2.0 are still going strong. (Ben famously called their marriage “work” in his Oscar speech, but I don’t think that’s so wrong.) And J.Lo is now a mama of two (with ex-husband Marc Anthony) in a long-term relationship with Casper Smart.

Both Jens found their own version of happily ever after, but who scored the better engagement ring from Ben Affleck? Which Jen’s ring would you want to wear on your left hand?

I’d like a non-Hollywood-size version of Jennifer Lopez. I’m just so drawn to that pale pink diamond.

Photos 1-3: Fairchild Archive. Photo 4: Getty Images.