Let’s Discuss Jessica Alba’s Engagement Ring Switcheroo

If you’ve spent any amount of time staring at Jessica Alba’s left hand {cough, guilty } they you’re familiar with her engagement ring, a cushion-cut diamond (I think) on gold pave band.

So I was totally surprised when I saw this pic, taken post-engagement, pre-wedding:

Here’s a slightly clearer shot.

Looks to me like a slightly larger diamond—although it might be the same diamond—but the bottom ring is in a platinum or white-gold halo setting. My guess: Jess was feeling so-so about the original setting and asked her guy to take the bling factor down a notch.

What do you think’s going on with Jessica Alba’s ring finger? Which ring do you like best? And would you have the guts to ask your guy to swap your setting?